Red flags on a car shipping offer
While you are still on the phone, listen for a few stops. No legal name you can find at FMCSA. A price far under the range. Money due before a carrier is named. A demand to pay by wire, gift card, or a payment app. A price that can change after you pay, with no refund to the card. One of those is enough to end the call.
Key facts
- Check the number they read you
- FMCSA's 2015 advisory says to avoid a transporter or broker that does not show an MC docket number, and to search that number.
- Source: FMCSA consumer advisory, February 10, 2015
- Low price plus a wallet deposit
- BBB's July 21, 2023 alert describes a low quote, a deposit of a few hundred dollars by digital wallet, and a pickup that never happens.
- Source: BBB vehicle-transport scam alert
- Payment method
- The same alert says to pay by credit card, and not by wire or prepaid debit card. Wallet payments are treated as cash.
- Source: BBB vehicle-transport scam alert
- Broker in disguise
- A broker must not advertise as the carrier. If the caller will not say which one they are, pause.
- Source: 49 CFR 371.7
The sources are listed on this page.
Use this list while the caller is still talking. You do not need to accuse anyone. You need to hear whether the offer survives six checks. RideShipper will not call you to demand a deposit. A caller who says otherwise is not this service.
The list to keep by the phone
Stop the call if you hear any of these.
- [ ] They will not give a legal name, a USDOT number, or an MC number.
- [ ] You search the number and the legal name is a different company.
- [ ] They will not say whether they are the broker or the carrier.
- [ ] The price is far under the range for your route, and they need a deposit today to hold it.
- [ ] No carrier is named, and the money is due anyway.
- [ ] They want Zelle, a wire, a gift card, a prepaid card, or only a payment app.
- [ ] The price can change after you pay, and the deposit is kept if you refuse the new price.
- [ ] They tell you not to check reviews, FMCSA, or the contract.
Write the caller's name, the company, the callback number, and the price on the back of the page before you hang up. You may need it if a charge appears later.
What each box means
No number, or the wrong name. FMCSA's advisory, updated February 10, 2015, says interstate transporters and brokers must be registered and should show an MC docket number. Search it on the Company Snapshot. Digits that belong to a different legal name are not a license for this caller. That mismatch is the whole check. The click path is how to check FMCSA authority.
They will not say broker or carrier. A broker has to show broker status in its advertising and may not present itself as the carrier (49 CFR 371.7). "We handle everything" is not an answer. Ask again. The difference is broker versus carrier.
A price that only works if you pay now. The BBB alert of July 21, 2023 says a price significantly under the going rate is how the deposit gets collected. There is no official price list for every lane. Compare the number with a dated range. A deposit of a few hundred dollars through a digital wallet, before anyone arrives, is the pattern the alert describes. One published example was 50 dollars through PayPal to a company the consumer could not find on the USDOT site.
The payment method. The alert says wallet payments are essentially cash, tells you to use a credit card, and says not to wire money or use a prepaid debit card. A Zelle or gift-card demand is a stop, not a negotiation. Details are on Zelle, wire, and gift-card requests.
A price that is allowed to move, with your deposit stuck. That is the bait. The first number wins the fee. The second number arrives when a carrier is found. If you cannot cancel and get the card credited, you are paying for the right to be repriced. Read bait-and-switch quotes before you say yes.
Quote checker
After the call, put the price, the route, and the deposit terms into the quote checker. It compares the number with the range and flags warning signs in the offer. It does not clear the company. The scam warning-sign checker asks a short set of questions about the offer and returns the signs that match. Use it without reading your phone number to another form.
What is not a red flag by itself
A company that asks for a credit-card deposit after a carrier is named, with a written refund rule, is using a common contract term. A price inside the range that still feels high may be an enclosed trailer, a car that does not run, or a tight date. Ask them to name the reason. A broker who says "I am the broker" is doing what the regulation requires. None of those is the list above.
If several boxes are checked, do not send a "small" fee to keep them talking. Small was enough in the BBB example. The longer pattern page is common car shipping scams. The questions to ask instead, if the offer is still alive, are questions to ask before you pay.
Questions
How many red flags are too many?
One hard stop is enough. A wire demand, a gift card, or a legal name that does not match the federal record is enough to hang up. A low price by itself is a reason to compare, not an automatic hang-up, if the company is findable and the contract locks the number.
The caller says the flag list is for scams and they are legitimate. Now what?
Ask them to pass the list. Legal name, federal number, cargo certificate, price clause, and a credit-card payment. A legitimate company can do those things. A speech about reputation is not a substitute.
Can I run the check without starting more calls?
Yes. Do not read your phone number to a second website to "verify" the first caller. Use the quote checker and the federal lookup yourself. Emailing yourself a RideShipper range does not send your number to carriers.